Blatant advertising is one of the few speedy-deletion criteria that never mentions sources. G11 asks a different question: could this page survive ordinary editing, or would it need to be rebuilt from nothing to read like an encyclopedia entry instead of a brochure? A subject can clear the notability bar by a wide margin and still lose its page within the hour, because the writing itself is the problem, not the evidence behind it.
The test an administrator applies is close to mechanical. Strip the superlatives — leading, pioneering, best-in-class, world-renowned — and look at what remains. If a page survives that cut, the tag doesn't apply, however much shine it loses. If what's left is three sentences and a founding date, the page was never really an article. It was marketing with footnotes attached.
Clients reach for the same defense every time: 'None of this is false. Every word of it checks out.' Usually it does. Accuracy was never the test G11 applies. A sentence calling a firm 'the undisputed leader in sustainable packaging' can be perfectly true and still fail the criterion, because what's being measured is function, not veracity — whether a sentence exists to inform a reader or to recruit one.
We watched the split play out twice in the same month, on two drafts with very different sourcing behind them. A biotech client arrived with the kind of record most reviewers call comfortable: four independent trade-press features, a regulatory filing, a profile in a regional business magazine. The draft built on top of that sourcing read like a pitch deck — 'pioneering,' a paragraph on the founders' vision, a client roster rendered as prose. An administrator tagged it under G11 nine minutes after it reached the main namespace. Nobody had opened the citations yet.
A regional logistics company that same month had thinner sourcing — two features in a trade publication, one piece in a city business journal, the kind of record that makes reviewers argue. Its draft went to a full seven-day deletion discussion instead of a speedy tag, and it held. Every sentence in it traced back to a cited fact: the year of incorporation, the number of warehouses operated, a labor dispute a local paper had covered independently of the company. Editors argued at length about whether the sourcing cleared the bar. Nobody argued about the prose.
Pages that exist to promote a company, product or individual, and that would need to be fundamentally rewritten rather than edited to read as an encyclopedia article, are deleted without a discussion.
Rewriting a promotional draft is not a matter of softening the same claims. It means removing the ones that carry no citation and replacing them with facts a stranger with no stake in the company could have written just as easily — the market it competes in, the product it recalled, the year its reported revenue last fell. A sentence that would survive being written by someone who has never heard of the client is the only kind this criterion can't reach.
Sourcing earns a subject a place in the encyclopedia. The sentences sitting around that sourcing decide whether the page describing them is still there the next time anyone goes looking.