NotabiliasNotabilias
Journal

Notes on notability

Field notes on what earns a place in the encyclopedia, and what does not.

November 22, 2026 · 1 min read

The review you paid for

Kirkus and Publishers Weekly each run a second review track behind the one most readers recognize — unsolicited and free on one side, submitted and paid on the other. Wikipedia's guideline for books only credits the first, and the finished page never says which one you're looking at.

Read the article →
November 21, 2026 · 1 min read

'None of this is false'

Wikipedia's criterion for blatant advertising, G11, never asks whether a claim is true. It asks whether the sentence exists to inform a reader or to recruit one — which is why a well-sourced draft can vanish in minutes while a thinner one survives a week of discussion.

Read the article →
November 20, 2026 · 1 min read

Caution that outlives the subject

Wikipedia's policy for living persons technically ends when its subject dies, yet editors are asked to keep its caution alive for as long as grief does — a narrow, deliberately vague rule that decides less than most families, or the firms managing a page for them, assume.

Read the article →
November 19, 2026 · 1 min read

The ticket behind a free photo

A free-licensed headshot can earn its place in a Wikipedia infobox, but the proof has to clear a private volunteer queue most readers never hear of — and the ticket number it leaves behind is the only trace that the right person actually said yes.

Read the article →