NotabiliasNotabilias
Journal

The copyright check every new article passes through

Published November 17, 2026 · 1 min read

Within minutes of a new page being saved, Wikipedia already knows how closely its prose matches something else on the open web. A tool called Earwig's Copyvio Detector takes the submission, finds its best match online, and reports a single number: a percentage of resemblance. New Page Patrol and the Articles for Creation queue both run every draft through it before a human reviewer reads past the first sentence.

The threshold is rough but consequential. Somewhere past fifty percent, a reviewer is expected to read the matched page directly rather than trust the score. Past roughly seventy, the usual move is a speedy-deletion tag under criterion G12 — unambiguous copyright infringement — logged and gone, often within the hour, before anyone has asked whether the subject is notable at all.

The page most likely to trip it is rarely copied from a competitor's Wikipedia article. It is copied from the subject's own materials: the paragraph that already cleared legal, that the communications team signed off on months ago, pasted from the company's 'About' page into the new draft because it already says, in the agreed words, exactly what the executive is supposed to be known for.

Declining — this reads like a company bio, not an encyclopedia entry. Please rewrite it in your own words, or have the copyright holder release the text first.
a typical Articles for Creation decline note

That instinct — reuse the sentence everyone already approved — runs straight into how Wikipedia's licence works. Save text to the encyclopedia and it is released, immediately and irrevocably, under a share-alike licence that lets anyone copy, edit, and resell it. A corporate 'About' page was never written with that in mind, and nothing about the company wanting its own words there changes what licence those words were actually published under.

The detector does not know, or care, that the subject supplied the sentence willingly. It only measures whether the sentence already exists somewhere else in roughly that shape. Close paraphrase counts as much as a direct copy: swapping a handful of words while keeping the original's structure and rhythm reads the same to a reviewer as pasting it outright.

There is a formal way through this, when the original wording genuinely needs to stay. Wikipedia's Volunteer Response Team can log a release from the actual copyright holder, placing the text on record under a compatible licence before the article is judged on anything else. It takes days rather than minutes, and it changes nothing about whether the subject clears notability — it only clears the one hurdle that sits in front of that question.

An article can have every source an editor could ask for and still die on this point, because the copyvio check was never reading for truth. It was reading for whose sentence it was. The paragraphs that survive it are usually the ones written new, from the sources as evidence rather than as a script — including, and especially, the sources the subject wrote about themselves.

Notabilias
The Notabilias Podcast

Every note becomes a conversation.

Adrian & Nora, daily, on what earns a place in the world’s encyclopedia.

Human-written episodes; the voices of Adrian & Nora are AI-generated.